Kentucky Man Sues Doctor For Amputating His Penis | TigerDroppings.com

Posted byMessage
Gujam8
Member since Jun 2010
2361 posts

Kentucky Man Sues Doctor For Amputating His Penis



FRANKFORT, Ky. (AP) — A Kentucky man did not consent to have his penis amputated and the doctor who performed the surgery had options other than removing the organ, even though cancer had been found during a surgery, an attorney argued Tuesday to the Kentucky Court of Appeals.

Kevin George, the lawyer for Phillip Seaton of Waddy, told the appeals panel that the medical waiver signed by his client contains extremely broad language and that Dr. John Patterson should have sought consent before removing the penis.

“The point is … a patient has a right,” George said. “The doctor does not have the right to do whatever he wants, even if it turns out to be reasonable.”

Judges Janet Stumbo and Donna Dixon took in the 30 minutes of arguments in Frankfort over whether a judge erred in the jury instructions and if the pre-surgery medical consent form was valid or the language in it proved to be too vague. Judge Michael Caperton missed the arguments. Stumbo said Caperton mistakenly went to Louisville for the case, but would listen to a recording of it later.

Stumbo said a decision is expected in about two months.

Patterson, a Kentucky-based urologist, maintains he found cancer in the man’s penis during surgery and that it had to be removed. The patient claims the surgery was supposed to be a circumcision and he never authorized the amputation, nor was he given a chance to seek a second opinion.

The Seatons sued Patterson in Shelby County Circuit Court in 2008 after an operation that resulted in the amputation. Seaton, now in his 60s, was having the procedure on Oct. 19, 2007, to better treat inflammation.

The Seatons also sued Jewish Hospital, where the surgery took place. The hospital settled with the Seaton and his wife, Deborah, for an undisclosed amount.

Seaton, sporting glasses and a long, gray and white ponytail, sat quietly as the attorneys recounted the details of the case and argued over whether the judge’s rulings and the jury’s outcome were correct.

“No comment right now,” Seaton said as he left the courtroom.

Both sides of the case agree that Seaton had cancer in his penis, but the main point of contention is over whether Patterson acted reasonably in removing the organ or could amputation have been delayed to give Seaton time to seek other medical options.

Clay Robinson, the attorney for Patterson, noted that Seaton, although he claimed to be mostly illiterate, signed two separate consent forms before the surgery. When Patterson started the surgical procedure, he found no living tissue, instead revealing a cancer-riddled organ that needed removal, Robinson said.

“This case isn’t about a man’s penis being removed, it’s about cancer being removed,” Robinson said.

Stumbo noted that Patterson, after finding the cancer, didn’t momentarily halt the surgery and seek the consent of Deborah Seaton, who was outside the operating room.

Robinson said the couple had been separated at the time of the procedure.

“She was not designated as a medical decision maker for Mr. Seaton,” Robinson said.

George noted that Seaton signed the two consent forms in the days before the surgery, but said his client was basically illiterate and didn’t intend to give Paterson consent to amputate, only conduct a circumcision. Stumbo appeared to agree.

“I noticed these were very, very, very broad instructions,” Stumbo said.

Dixon asked why Patterson felt it was necessary to amputate as much of the penis as he did.

“Is there another procedure … he could have had that would have meant he wouldn’t have had to have part of his penis removed?” Dixon said.

“The direct answer is, no,” Robinson replied. “The removal of the cancer did not preclude his having his penis reconstructed.”

Stumbo, though, seemed troubled by Patterson’s decision to amputate the penis without seeking further consent to do so or giving Seaton an opportunity to explore other options.

“Was it truly an emergency?” Stumbo asked. “That’s the question.”

LINK /







Back to top
Share:
bigpetedatiga
LSU Fan
Alexandria, LA
Member since Aug 2009
5151 posts

re: Kentucky Man Sues Doctor For Amputating His Penis








Back to top
Walt OReilly
Arizona State Fan
Cubs Fan
Member since Oct 2005
82675 posts

re: Kentucky Man Sues Doctor For Amputating His Penis








Back to top
Tiger4Ever
UTEP Fan
Member since Aug 2003
35873 posts

re: Kentucky Man Sues Doctor For Amputating His Penis


This settles the circumcision debate.

Do it at birth...or else you risk unauthorized amputation of your/your son's dong.



This post was edited on 9/11 at 8:04 pm


Back to top
rballa19
LSU Fan
Lake Charles, LA
Member since Oct 2009
2673 posts

re: Kentucky Man Sues Doctor For Amputating His Penis


Wow. How would you like to go in and get circumcised and come out missing your dick!?





Back to top
MrBobDobalina
USA Fan
bad and rude, LA
Member since Oct 2011
1828 posts

re: Kentucky Man Sues Doctor For Amputating His Penis








Back to top
DrTyger
LSU Fan
Lake Charles
Member since Oct 2009
21974 posts

re: Kentucky Man Sues Doctor For Amputating His Penis


Was it squamous cell carcinoma? If so, the dude was gonna lose his penis anyway so the doc just saved him an extra hospital bill and another risky surgery.





Back to top
crimsonsaint
New Orleans Saints Fan
Member since Nov 2009
32719 posts
 Online 

re: Kentucky Man Sues Doctor For Amputating His Penis


I would have beat his arse when I woke up.





Back to top
lsufanva
LSU Fan
sandston virginia
Member since Aug 2009
6398 posts

re: Kentucky Man Sues Doctor For Amputating His Penis


That doctor would have a little more to worry about than a lawsuit if he cut my dick off before checking with me 1st. Let's be real, at that point most men would consider their life over. No reason not to kill that bastard.





Back to top
Napoleon
New Orleans Saints Fan
Member since Dec 2007
36930 posts

re: Kentucky Man Sues Doctor For Amputating His Penis


quote:


Do it at birth...or else you risk unauthorized amputation of your/your son's dong.



this







Back to top
  Replies (0)
dtrack22
Boise State Fan
WTF am I doing here?
Member since Jul 2012
1135 posts

re: Kentucky Man Sues Doctor For Amputating His Penis








Back to top
Gujam8
Member since Jun 2010
2361 posts

re: Kentucky Man Sues Doctor For Amputating His Penis


quote:

I would have beat his arse when I woke up.


Only thing to do since you won't be beating yourself any longer.






Back to top
  Replies (0)
RonFNSwanson
New Orleans Pelicans Fan
University of LSU
Member since Mar 2012
15556 posts

re: Kentucky Man Sues Doctor For Amputating His Penis


Took off a little too much on that circumcision eh





Back to top
  Replies (0)
fillmoregandt
Ole Miss Fan
Over the Mountain,bro
Member since Nov 2009
6215 posts

re: Kentucky Man Sues Doctor For Amputating His Penis


Like a haircut "just take a little off the top"

And getting shaved instead.

Unfortunately the guy's penis wont grow back






Back to top
brewhan davey
USA Fan
Audubon Place
Member since Sep 2010
25929 posts

re: Kentucky Man Sues Doctor For Amputating His Penis








Back to top
  Replies (0)
Titus Pullo
Alabama Fan
5100 miles SE of Dutch Harbor, AK
Member since Feb 2011
15745 posts

re: Kentucky Man Sues Doctor For Amputating His Penis




I was just about to post

"Alabama man beats doctor to death for amputation of penis".

That's what would happen if it were me.






Back to top
7thWardTiger
LSU Fan
Richmond, Texas
Member since Nov 2009
22369 posts

re: Kentucky Man Sues Doctor For Amputating His Penis








Back to top
meaux5
LSU Fan
Lafayette/BR
Member since Sep 2010
8726 posts

re: Kentucky Man Sues Doctor For Amputating His Penis


that fricking sucks





Back to top
  Replies (0)
crimsonsaint
New Orleans Saints Fan
Member since Nov 2009
32719 posts
 Online 

re: Kentucky Man Sues Doctor For Amputating His Penis


I mean seriously. Let the fricking dude wake up first and tell him what's up. Dude comes in to get circumcised looking forward to better sex and wakes up without a dick.





Back to top
willymeaux
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Mar 2012
2736 posts

re: Kentucky Man Sues Doctor For Amputating His Penis


how the hell does he fap or piss????





Back to top


Back to top