Ranaudo at his best was better than Coleman
Coleman was arguably the most important player for LSU his last 2 years.
In 2009, he had more innings pitched than Ranaudo, more wins, fewer walks, better WHIP, better ERA, etc
I mean I love Ranaudo, but come on. When Coleman has him beat on ERA, wins, and innings pitched, it's kinda hard to say Ranaudo was better.
And I'm not even going to use the argument that Coleman had a sub 3.00 ERA in the majors last season and Ranaudo is still in A ball