Did Caprica suck?
Caprica was good, if you REALLY like BSG. I enjoyed it......but....
What they did in those first two seasons should have been done in one. The epilogue at the end of Season should have been Season 2, that was the big problem.
The epilogue was worth the rest of the show, honestly. It was the good. But also that sad, because we would never get to see it.
By trying to distance themselves too much from BSG to expand their fanbase, they got too far away from BSG for two full seasons. That sucked.