re: X Factor (Fox) Season Long Discussion Thread

Watching the tape.

Tate was okay. I like that song, but didn't love the performance.

Diamond White brought her game tonight. I thought she was awesome. Big step up. I got teary eyed. Good job on picking that song.

EmblemThree was just okay. Nothing special this week.

Arin did a nice job. Nothing outstanding. I agree with Arin. He does need to him. He does need to do upbeat songs. He can't do those slow tunes well. Not sure he'll get another shot, though. I think he goes this week.

Did Khloe pump up her lips some more? She looks strange and is even more annoying. I think someone is in her ear telling her every move to make. I'll be thankful when she gets canned.

Cece, once again, looks like cross between a bad Marilyn Monroe impersonator and street walker. Sheesh, the start of the song was awful and pitchy as hell. She hit some big notes but this was another train wreck for me. I wasn't moved at all and I'm a marshmallow. She needs a dye job back to brunette. The judges must have ear problems. Sheesh. This is so damn produced. The show wants her to stay. Oh we'll.

Fifth Harmony-I don't know. It was good but not as good as I think they could have done it. I think they could have had bigger moments.

Is Khloe supposed to be talking her faves? I think not. I like Carly Rose too, but please.

Beatrice was much better than last week. I like her voice. I think she bought another week, but I agree that she should do something different. I'd like to see her do something else.

Vino was very good. I didn't think his spin arse as great as the judges thought but its pretty hard not to feel that song. He's definitely safe and a contender. He'll get the patriotic vote this week for sure.

Not sure Paige dug herself out. It wasn't a great performance. Better than Cece, though. Wrong song in my opinion. No wow moments.

Carly Rose- I got chills during the first notes and they got worse as the song went on. She just made mincemeat out of everyone else. I love the song anyway. Fabulous! Best version ever and I've heard it a lot. I want to rewrite my notes above.

I swear Khloe's lips are so pumped that she can't keep them together. They're pulling toward her nose.

I typed this on my phone so I probably have typos everywhere. Tough noogs.

Now, going to read y'all's posts not that they matter.