The age old "why did they change the bats" argument (some interesting numbers) - Page 2 - TigerDroppings.com

Posted byMessage
ToulatownTiger
Southeastern LA Fan
Louisiana
Member since Oct 2012
2861 posts

re: The age old "why did they change the bats" argument (some interesting numbers)


High school used the same exact BESR bats as college. And now use the same BBCOR bats.





Back to top
Vlad The Inhaler
Colorado State Fan
Colorado
Member since Sep 2008
3118 posts

re: The age old "why did they change the bats" argument (some interesting numbers)


Great post. Yeah, wtf?





Back to top
LSU6262
LSU Fan
Member since Jun 2008
2296 posts

re: The age old "why did they change the bats" argument (some interesting numbers)


let's compare amateur athletes across 300 teams to pro athletes across 30 teams; yeah, that makes sense.

hmm, I wonder what the average bench press is for each team. I bet it's lower for college than mlb. stats only really work when all the variables are considered.



This post was edited on 6/16 at 6:39 am


Back to top
catholictigerfan
LSU Fan
Member since Oct 2009
38241 posts

re: The age old "why did they change the bats" argument (some interesting numbers)


when you compare MLB bats to the current college bats they are pretty much the same.

there are two reasons why MLB has a larger HR per game average

1. its the MLB guys hit the ball harder there they are better at hitting are stronger are able to square the ball up better. It makes sense that they would hit the ball out more
2. the baseball less drag, not sure that would make a .5 difference though.

You don't consider that MLB guys hit the ball better then college guys so if they were even with HR per game than the college game would be easier to hit the ball out with, and if MLB guys used the same bat the HR per game would be over 1.






Back to top
Lacour
Member since Nov 2009
29086 posts

re: The age old "why did they change the bats" argument (some interesting numbers)


OP, get over it man.

It's not the United Nations. It's just a damn game.






Back to top
LSUNV
LSU Fan
Whoopassville
Member since Feb 2011
10496 posts

re: The age old "why did they change the bats" argument (some interesting numbers)


NCAA s stupid for changing bats

frick Major League Baseball. Haven't watched a game in years. I hope the entire MLB league collapses.

I love high school and college that is all






Back to top
LSUNV
LSU Fan
Whoopassville
Member since Feb 2011
10496 posts

re: The age old "why did they change the bats" argument (some interesting numbers)


quote:

1. its the MLB guys hit the ball harder there they are better at hitting are stronger are able to square the ball up better. It makes sense that they would hit the ball out more


Wrong, the sweet spot of a wooden bat, although small, has a hell of a lot more pop than BBCOR bats






Back to top
Tyghas
LSU Fan
New Orleans
Member since Jul 2004
956 posts

re: The age old "why did they change the bats" argument (some interesting numbers)


Good read. thanks.






Back to top
catholictigerfan
LSU Fan
Member since Oct 2009
38241 posts

re: The age old "why did they change the bats" argument (some interesting numbers)


quote:

Wrong, the sweet spot of a wooden bat, although small, has a hell of a lot more pop than BBCOR bats



thanks for telling me.






Back to top
Ironhead985
Southern Fan
Bring it, La
Member since Jun 2013
2978 posts

re: The age old "why did they change the bats" argument (some interesting numbers)


Why not just have them use the MLB wooden bats? Couldn't be worst than the "dead bats" we have now, could it and if its all about "safety" why not bring the fences in a bit?


This post was edited on 6/16 at 7:58 am


Back to top
BestBanker
New Orleans Saints Fan
stuck in a moment
Member since Nov 2011
3054 posts

re: The age old "why did they change the bats" argument (some interesting numbers)


Agree.
How many times have I stood up at the sound and appearance of what should be a home run only to see it fall 5-10 ft short. The bat change did severely alter the long ball game. But, the kids will adjust.






Back to top
dreaux
LSU Fan
baton rouge
Member since Oct 2006
37028 posts

re: The age old "why did they change the bats" argument (some interesting numbers)


frick it. I'll take singles/dbles/triples all day.

Hit the gaps!






Back to top
tigerfoot
LA-Monroe Fan
Alexandria
Member since Sep 2006
17394 posts

re: The age old "why did they change the bats" argument (some interesting numbers)


So, MLB wanted a truer representation of what a player could do with similar technology to theirs.

OP has determined thru research that infact, better, stronger, older, more experienced players that are brought in from a globe and paid millions hit more home runs when equipment is similar to amateur players that may still be going thru puberty.

Most teams don't have a single player that will ever see a major league ballpark, and we compare the two.

Legit.



This post was edited on 6/16 at 8:24 am


Back to top
tigerfoot
LA-Monroe Fan
Alexandria
Member since Sep 2006
17394 posts

re: The age old "why did they change the bats" argument (some interesting numbers)


quote:

Wrong, the sweet spot of a wooden bat, although small, has a hell of a lot more pop than BBCOR bats


So the major league players really aren't better. Whew.






Back to top
jmac63
LSU Fan
USA
Member since Oct 2007
311 posts

re: The age old "why did they change the bats" argument (some interesting numbers)


quote:

hell they draft high school kids who use much less regulated bats than the college BESR bats.


not true - HS uses the same standard






Back to top
upgrade
LSU Fan
Pina Coladaburg
Member since Jul 2011
2098 posts

re: The age old "why did they change the bats" argument (some interesting numbers)


The OP never compared to or even mentioned the 90's bats.
I'm pretty sure everyone realizes those were ridiculous.

The MLB hitters are the best in the world, who would have thought that?

College baseball needs just a bit more power back in the game.
I do believe the complete team should have the advantage, though.






Back to top
Oopskie
McNeese State Fan
Thread Killing since 07
Member since Apr 2007
1946 posts

re: The age old "why did they change the bats" argument (some interesting numbers)


Comparing MLB to NCAA ball

This was posted before but fits in this thread






Back to top
Brohypnol
Somewhere else
Member since Feb 2013
114 posts

re: The age old "why did they change the bats" argument (some interesting numbers)


But, if a pitcher gets hit by a line drive from a BBCOR.... It doesn't hurt... Only the BESR bats cause line drives to hurt.





Back to top
thunderbird1100
LSU Fan
GSU Eagles fan
Member since Oct 2007
35140 posts

re: The age old "why did they change the bats" argument (some interesting numbers)


quote:

You don't consider that MLB guys hit the ball better then college guys so if they were even with HR per game than the college game would be easier to hit the ball out with, and if MLB guys used the same bat the HR per game would be over 1.


I considered that just fine. I also considered pitchers have every advantage over hitters in college where as in the pros they don't. College pitchers have a larger strike zone, a gripper baseball and deadened bats to throw at. With only the bats being similar in MLB. That has produced less than half the amount of home runs in college now as MLB. Most people will say even the MLB game was better with more than it has now, and college has less than half that power. It's simply unacceptable baseball from a spectators standpoint.

Teams in college same to have adjusted well enough by now to the new bats and we see that at LSU for sure. Long gone are the days of stacking 6 foot plus 200 plus pound guys in the lineup. So the coaches have in turn made power numbers even worse because of the devaluing of the power game.

Once again, scouts can grade high school players out to be 7 figure contract guys without ever picking up a wood bat. College has wooden bat summer leagues to help scouts. Why did we need to change the bats so bad when the power numbers were so close to the professional product? It made the game much less exciting. That's really all it accomplished.






Back to top
thunderbird1100
LSU Fan
GSU Eagles fan
Member since Oct 2007
35140 posts

re: The age old "why did they change the bats" argument (some interesting numbers)


quote:

High school used the same exact BESR bats as college.


Maybe they are supposed to, but I highly doubt it's near as regulated and policed. I was at a high school tournament not too long ago and I can tell you those bats sounded nothing like the BBCOR college bats I hear in every LSU game.






Back to top


Back to top




//