O'Donnell's in Ponchatoula Recs | TigerDroppings.com

Posted byMessage
4LSU2
LSU Fan
Madisonville
Member since Dec 2009
22139 posts

O'Donnell's in Ponchatoula Recs


Wife and I are going out with another couple tomorrow nigh to this joint. The reservations were originally for Sal and Judy's, but were switched at the other couples' request.

Neither of us have been and were looking for some recommendations. TIA.







Back to top
Share:
4LSU2
LSU Fan
Madisonville
Member since Dec 2009
22139 posts

re: O'Donnell's in Ponchatoula Recs


I kinda figured it wasn't worth a shite. Thanks for the responses.





Back to top
El Josey Wales
LSU Fan
Greater Geismar
Member since Nov 2007
22710 posts

re: O'Donnell's in Ponchatoula Recs


As long as they have a liquor license, you will be fine.





Back to top
4LSU2
LSU Fan
Madisonville
Member since Dec 2009
22139 posts

re: O'Donnell's in Ponchatoula Recs


It is supposed to be a steak house and boasts "Fine Dining" on a standard google search. The problem is that one really can't view a menu on-line. Their webpage must've been created about the time Uncle Gore invented the world wide web. I will most likely have a few bottles of their best Berringer.





Back to top
CBLSU316
LSU Fan
Far Right of Left
Member since Jun 2008
8700 posts

re: O'Donnell's in Ponchatoula Recs


On the rocks?





Back to top
4LSU2
LSU Fan
Madisonville
Member since Dec 2009
22139 posts

re: O'Donnell's in Ponchatoula Recs


Only way to have it.





Back to top
El Josey Wales
LSU Fan
Greater Geismar
Member since Nov 2007
22710 posts

re: O'Donnell's in Ponchatoula Recs


I'm sure your lovely pregnant bride will have a pleasant evening with you.





Back to top
CBLSU316
LSU Fan
Far Right of Left
Member since Jun 2008
8700 posts

re: O'Donnell's in Ponchatoula Recs


She only pretends to get frustrated with 4's antics......it's a front, she loves it.





Back to top
cssamerican
New Orleans Saints Fan
Member since Mar 2011
2246 posts

re: O'Donnell's in Ponchatoula Recs


I ate their a few years back and it was pretty good. The gumbo was spot on, and I had the seared duck breast which I enjoyed.





Back to top
  Replies (0)
BehindtheWoodshed
Stanford Fan
Louisiana
Member since Sep 2007
1684 posts

re: O'Donnell's in Ponchatoula Recs


I've heard really good things about the place, but I have yet to eat their myself.





Back to top
  Replies (0)
El Josey Wales
LSU Fan
Greater Geismar
Member since Nov 2007
22710 posts

re: O'Donnell's in Ponchatoula Recs


Take pics for the review. Pic threads are quite popular around here lately.





Back to top
  Replies (0)
El Josey Wales
LSU Fan
Greater Geismar
Member since Nov 2007
22710 posts

re: O'Donnell's in Ponchatoula Recs


I am anxiously awaiting your review of this place tonight.





Back to top
  Replies (0)
NatalbanyTigerFan
LSU Fan
On the water somewhere
Member since Oct 2007
5407 posts

re: O'Donnell's in Ponchatoula Recs


Can't remember where Chef Phil O'Donnell worked before but I think it may have been Jacmel Inn that everyone raves about.
I've only had the steak there and they are excellent.
One of those little "hole in the wall" places that you'll love.






Back to top
4LSU2
LSU Fan
Madisonville
Member since Dec 2009
22139 posts

re: O'Donnell's in Ponchatoula Recs


quote:

One of those little "hole in the wall" places that you'll love.


Good to hear.






Back to top
El Josey Wales
LSU Fan
Greater Geismar
Member since Nov 2007
22710 posts

re: O'Donnell's in Ponchatoula Recs


Finally some promising news.





Back to top
rented mule
LSU Fan
Member since Sep 2005
728 posts

re: O'Donnell's in Ponchatoula Recs


That place was on that health inspector show, on food network the other night. Their kitchen was straight up nasty! The chef refused to wear a hair net on his zztop beard.
LINK Staged or not, I don't see how anyone would want to be on that show, seems like horrible advertisement.






Back to top
El Josey Wales
LSU Fan
Greater Geismar
Member since Nov 2007
22710 posts

re: O'Donnell's in Ponchatoula Recs








Back to top
4LSU2
LSU Fan
Madisonville
Member since Dec 2009
22139 posts

re: O'Donnell's in Ponchatoula Recs


Food was good.
Service was autrocious.

The server had no clue what the night's specials were and had to resort to his cheat board to complete his spill.

We ordered with an order of the crab cakes and BBQ shrimp. After 4 drinks, the appetizers came 90 minutes after we placed the appetizer order. Apps were good, but the wait was ridiculous. We then placed our salad and main course order.

3 drinks later, the staff placed chilled silverware on the table for a salad experience like no othere. By the time the salads arrived, humidity took over, and the silverware was hotter than a $2 pistol. The onion vinagerette dressing was good, but the wait was absurb.

2 and 1/2 hours after we sat down to eat, the main dishes arrived. My ribeye was cooked fine (medium rare), wife had the medium filet. I had a potato/ andouille concoction, she had asparagus and a potato medley of sorts.

The waiter had the perception of having been let out of GB Cooley just prior to his shift. The manager was from Marrero and that speaks for itself. There was no talent on the clock whatsoever for a fella to gawk at, and the restroom area has a huge traffic bump in front of it that tends to throw a drunk fella off of his game.

All in all, good times (Blues Man on jukebox) good food, but beyond shitty service. $150 down the pipe and we are home to tell about it.






Back to top
El Josey Wales
LSU Fan
Greater Geismar
Member since Nov 2007
22710 posts

re: O'Donnell's in Ponchatoula Recs


quote:

The waiter had the perception of having been let out of GB Cooley just prior to his shift.








Back to top
  Replies (0)


Back to top