| Saints Talk |
| Return to Board • Menu • Bottom | Page 1 of 2  |
| Message |
| Top Five Saints RBs Posted by Sophandros At the end of the column:  on 5/4 at 10:33 amLINK quote: Yes, I just teased it for you. Reply • Back to Top |
| enlightenment to me: Hilliard threw four touchdowns on option plays in his career; his quarterback rating was 141.4. pretty funny about George Rogers and Michael Turner- perhaps the worst pass catching successful RBs in NFL history. --thx for a non scandal thread soph! looking forward to the 3 replies it gets  This post was edited on 5/4 at 11:05 am Reply • Back to Top |
| Fred McAfee 5th?? I would go Heyward over him. Reply • Back to Top |
Damn, they are pretty rough on those guys. I'd say McCallister then Hilliard then the rest. quote: Yeah, maybe they just added up his special team pro bowl apperances or something.  Reply • Back to Top |
| I'd have to put George Rogers at the top. He was a joy to watch. Hilliard a close second Reply • Back to Top |
Reggie...  Reply • Back to Top |
quote: Deuce Sproles PT Cruiser Ivory Ingram BLAM done. Reply • Back to Top |
| What about Mayes? Reply • Back to Top |
quote: I'm too young to remember watching Rogers, but Duece has to be at the top. Hilliard had all the records and Duece broke all those. I'm sure Rogers was on bad teams, but still. Does Ironhead make the list? A fullback is a type of RB. Reply • Back to Top |
| Deuce at the top Rogers Hilliard And some controversy: Ricky Bush Ricky was great and dominant. Bush was a big part of rejuvenating the team after Katrina. Reply • Back to Top |
Posted by ScoopAndScore on 5/4 at 2:17 pm to Sophandros Reuben Mayes is #5. Deuce, George Rogers, Chuck Muncie, Hilliard, Mayes ETA: Ricky Williams is prob #6. And can we put Earl Campbell on the list? This post was edited on 5/4 at 2:19 pm Reply • Back to Top |
| 1. Deuce 2. Hilliard 3. Mayes 4. Muncie (probably the most talented of them all, but on drugs.) 5. Hayward (also a natural talent with good feet, but too heavy. He could have been great) Reply • Back to Top |
| I'd take: Deuce Rogers Hilliard Muncie then Sproles or Reggie just to have a little more change of pace. Reply • Back to Top |
| Deuce George Rogers Ironhead Reuben Mayes Dalton Hilliard Reply • Back to Top |
quote: I'll never forget the game against the Falcons when he broke through the line and had a clear path to the endzone but then blew out his hammy and had the defender take the ball from him. Reply • Back to Top |
| My List: 1. Deuce 2. George Rogers 3. Hilliard 4. Ricky Williams 5. Muncie Trouble is, apparently none stick around long enough to really make a great name... Reply • Back to Top |
| What about Jess Phillips, Alvin Maxon ( held the single game record for many years), tony Galbreath??? Hilliard is my all time favorite. Reply • Back to Top |
Thunder and Lightning  Reply • Back to Top |
| Hokie Frickin Gajan!!!!!!! Reply • Back to Top |
| McAllister Rogers Muncie Hilliard Galbreath Mayes Livingston P.Thomas T.Baker Heyward Sproles R.Williams R.Bush Jess Phillips Ingram H.Stevens Maxson Hokie Ivory Strachan This post was edited on 5/7 at 9:30 am Reply • Back to Top • Refresh |
| Return to Board | ||
  Page 1 of 2  | ||
on 5/4 at 10:52 am to 
on 5/4 at 11:59 am to .gif){kind=icon}
on 5/4 at 1:09 pm to 
on 5/4 at 1:15 pm to