| Music Board |
| Return to Board • Menu • Bottom | Page 1 of 6  |
| Message |
| Do you consider Britney Spears a "musician"? Posted by TheDoc Yay or nay? on 4/30 at 6:16 amReply • Back to Top |
| No, a performer Reply • Back to Top |
| I'd agree Reply • Back to Top |
| I consider her an entertainer, not a musician. Reply • Back to Top |
| not really... unless you consider one's voice a musical instrument. Reply • Back to Top |
Yeah, I don't consider a voice an musical instrument. Neither does anyone else with any musical training.  Reply • Back to Top |
| I don't have any kind of musical training. I just always thought musicians play music ....with instruments. Reply • Back to Top |
| Real trained singers are definitely musicians. Listen to some Sarah Vaughan improv (jazz) or any opera and you will hear the difference. The voice can be as much an instrument as a saxophone or flute. This is not, however, the case with Britney. Reply • Back to Top |
quote: What makes her different? Reply • Back to Top |
quote: She is a complete shite singer, and has no idea how to use her voice musically. She got famous because she was hot, and purred seductively in a plaid skirt school girl outfit and red spandex. There is nothing wrong with that, and I aint hatin homegirl. She has had some very catchy songs that are fun to listen to (not that she wrote them). But lets not mistake an image driven sex star for a great artist or musician. Reply • Back to Top |
| So do you consider Adele a musician or Celine dion? Reply • Back to Top |
quote: THIS. A gifted singer/voice is an amazing instrument. Reply • Back to Top |
she is a performer/entertainer/dancer, but I do not consider her a musician. quote: actually, she has co-written a few of her songs and there may be one or two she wrote entirely on her own. Reply • Back to Top |
quote: That's a figure of speech though. Your voice is not a musical instrument in the strict definition. Reply • Back to Top |
quote:  Reply • Back to Top |
quote: Nailed it. Vocalists can be as much of a musician as the guy plunking the bass. Reply • Back to Top |
quote: If you are looking at strict definitions, she would be a musician. quote: Reply • Back to Top |
| No. Reply • Back to Top |
quote: A musician who plays no musical instrument Reply • Back to Top |
quote: So britney spears is a musician? Reply • Back to Top • Refresh |
| Return to Board | ||
  Page 1 of 6  | ||
on 4/30 at 6:19 am to 
on 4/30 at 7:10 am to 
on 4/30 at 7:44 am to 
on 4/30 at 1:02 pm to