re: Bahamas or Roatan

Grand Cayman is nice but not my cup of tea. I do think you'd have an enjoyable time there. Again I don't see it as a golf cart type of island. Isla Mujeres sort of wins that one hands down with the easy driving in a cart and multiple stops to eat drink and walk the trails if you get down to Punta Sur.

Holbox is quant and a chill and relax kind of place. The only downside is if you go at a time when the sargassum is bad. They clean it daily but you're still stuck with it to a degree. Holbox is more of a walk aroung place because much of the island is a nature preserve which, to my understanding is now off limits.