All-inclusive recommendations for a ten-year anniversary

Next April (2025) will mark ten years for my wife and I and we've started talks on a trip (sans our three kids ). We did a Sandals resort for our honeymoon and really enjoyed it. Looking for something similar. Just relaxing near a beach being catered to for a few days with some exploring mixed in.

I've started looking into other Sandals resorts (we did Montego Bay in 2015) but should we be looking elsewhere? Will likely be a five day trip. Would like to keep everything under 5K and preferably short travel time (less than 5 hours). What I remember being nice about MB was the short travel from the Jamaican airport to the resort. Would like to keep that travel under an hour.

I know we are still a year out but likely never too early to plan for something like this. Would like to have it booked by this summer.