re: Finally Dennis Allen wins something.

Read the article...its right garbage.

I'm not trying to defend DA here, but the article makes 2 basic points about DA as to why he sucks:

1. He didn't fire Pete Carmichael after the 2022 season.
2. He fired Pete Carmichael after the 2023 season.

It basically says the very act of hiring a new offensive coordinator shows he is a bad coach.

Now, should he have fired PC after 2022? probably, but I can understand him not wanting to fully overhaul both the offensive and defensive staffs in the same offseason. He probably should have cleaned house when he first took the job, but he got it late because SP took a while to retire. it is what it is.

Then, it draws comparisons between Derek Carr and Klint Kubiak. Since DA threw all his eggs in a basket thinking that Carr could overcome Carmichael's shortcomings, now he is doing the same with Kubiak, thinking he will do the same with Carr. The only solution to that argument is to not have an OC at all. It's an illogical comparison.

It comes across as circular reasoning. DA's decisions are bad because he is a bad coach, and he is a bad coach because his decisions are bad. The argument covers the writer in case the Kubiak hiring works; he can argue that he never actually said that Kubiak was a bad hire even though he really did.

Plus, the actual survey gives using Taysom Hill on third down as a reason that DA is bad.

These are the same kind of people who are now claiming that Bill Bellicek was a bad coach.

Is DA one of the worst coaches in the NFL? His record says he is. This article is not a good support for that position.