re: Playoff Tie Controversy

If he was a member while the rule was in place then that should be on him.

You all agreed to rules outside the league then that should be what applies.

I would consider making a poll with the rest of your league to see their thoughts.

Is there a prize for 2nd and 3rd? If not maybe you could just have a 3 team final where highest scorer on the week wins. Whatever you decide maybe you could get input from the rest of the league.

Good luck.